Deciding Between Solid Surface or Quartz Countertops? Compare Your Options

It can be difficult to choose between popular materials in kitchen countertops. Both offer sleek, modern designs, but which is right for your home?

With the key similarities and differences outlined, you'll be able to weigh the pros and cons to make an informed decision for your space.

Countertop Composition

Understanding what solid surface and quartz countertops are made of provides insight into their inherent qualities and performance.

Solid Surface Countertops

Solid surface countertops are composed of a combination of mineral dust, like aluminum oxide or silicon dioxide, and acrylic or polyester resins. This blended material forms a seamless, solid sheet that can be fabricated for countertops.

Quartz Countertops

Quartz countertops contain ground natural quartz crystals combined with polyester resins. The quartz comprises 90-94% of the material, making the countertops very hard and durable.

Heat Tolerance

An important consideration for countertops is their ability to withstand heat. This will determine what type of cookware and baking you can do directly on the surface.

Solid Surface Heat Tolerance

Solid surface countertops have moderate heat resistance, generally withstanding temperatures up to 250-320degF before possible discoloration or damage. Pots and pans from cooking may leave marks if hot.

Quartz Heat Tolerance

Quartz has high heat tolerance, typically resisting temperatures up to about 680degF. This makes quartz very durable for hot cookware, baking, and more.

Durability and Longevity

Along with heat, countertops need to stand up to wear and tear. Durability impacts how surfaces hold up over time.

Solid Surface Durability

Solid surface is prone to scratches, cuts, and damage from impacts over time. Heavy objects may cause indentations. Regular care is required to maintain appearance.

Quartz Durability

Quartz is extremely hard and durable, resistant to scratches, cracks, chips, and heat damage. The material maintains its smooth appearance with minimal maintenance.

Maintenance and Cleaning

Upkeep requirements are another differentiator between solid surface and quartz countertops.

• Neither material needs sealing, as they are non-porous.
• This makes both solid surface and quartz very hygienic and easy to clean.
• Solid surface may require more frequent cleaning to prevent stains.
• Quartz rarely needs more than soap and water for cleaning.

Design Flexibility

The range of colors, finishes, and customization is important for complementing your kitchen's decor.

Solid Surface Designs

Solid surfaces come in a diverse array of colors and patterns. Matte or glossy finishes are possible. Seamless designs can be fabricated.

Quartz Designs

Quartz also offers a spectrum of colors and patterns, sometimes with exotic natural stone appearances. Matte to polished finishes give versatility.

Cost Comparison

Both solid surface and quartz are premium countertop materials that come at a cost. However, quartz is generally more expensive.

Solid Surface Cost

Solid surface countertops range from $50-100 per square foot installed. More simple designs may be less expensive.

Quartz Cost

Quartz typically costs $80-150 per square foot installed. The durability comes at a higher price point.

Pros and Cons of Each Material

To recap, here are the key advantages and disadvantages of solid surface versus quartz countertops:

Solid Surface Pros and Cons

Pros:

• Seamless appearance possible
• Wide range of colors
• Lower cost than quartz

Cons:

• Prone to scratches, cuts and damage
• Moderate heat resistance
• More frequent cleaning may be needed

Quartz Pros and Cons

Pros:

• Very durable and scratch/heat resistant
• Low maintenance
• Distinctive natural patterns

Cons:

• Higher cost than solid surface
• Some designs may have seams

Frequently Asked Questions

Is quartz or solid surface better for kitchen countertops?

Quartz is generally better for kitchens due to its superior durability, heat resistance, and stain resistance. It requires very little maintenance. Solid surface can work well but may show wear over time.

Is solid surface or quartz more durable?

Quartz is much harder and more durable than solid surface. Solid surface is susceptible to scratches, cuts, dents, and heat damage from pots/pans over time.

Which material is more heat resistant?

Quartz has excellent heat tolerance, resisting temperatures up to about 680degF. Solid surface has moderate heat resistance, withstanding approximately 250-320degF.

Do quartz or solid surface countertops need to be sealed?

Neither material requires sealing. Both quartz and solid surface are non-porous, so liquids don't penetrate them. This makes maintenance easy.

Quartz and solid surface both provide sleek, stylish countertops for kitchens and baths. For extreme durability, heat resistance, and low maintenance, quartz is generally the better performer. But solid surface can also be an attractive option at a lower price point. Consider how you use your space and the overall look you want to make the right choice.

With this comparison, you can decide between solid surface or quartz for countertops that will look great for a long time.