Deciding Between Granite and Quartzite Countertops? Compare the Key Differences
Granite and quartzite are two premium materials that have risen to the forefront with an increasing number of homeowners opting for natural stone countertops. Both offer durability and visual appeal. But is one better than the other? By examining a few key factors side-by-side, we can break down the pros and cons of each to help you make an informed decision.
Cost
When evaluating materials purely on price point, granite countertops are typically more budget-friendly than quartzite. As a common natural stone used in everything from monuments to residential projects, granite commands a lower price per square foot. Wholesale granite slabs can run anywhere from $40-70 per square foot on average. Quartzite slabs fall on the higher end of premium natural stones at $70-100 per square foot. Those material costs alone show granite pulls ahead as the more affordable option.
However, the full price difference depends on other project costs as well. Professional fabrication and installation fees can vary by hundreds or even thousands of dollars depending on the complexity of the job. In general though, granite will likely cost at least 15-20% less than a quartzite countertop project accounting for all expenses.
Appearance
When it comes to aesthetics, granite and quartzite both make stunning additions to any home. However, they differ quite a bit in their color palettes and patterns.
Color Range
Granite is prized for its diversity of colors, ranging from light ivories and creams to deeper blacks, browns, reds, greens and blues. Mineral deposits and color variations in the natural stone lend endless possibilities. Quartzite, on the other hand, typically appears in more neutral, earthy tones of white, gray, cream or brown. While beautiful, quartzite presents a comparatively limited selection of color options.
Patterns
Distinct veins and speckles throughout granite slabs create striking visual impact. Each piece offers a unique play on color and texture for a one-of-a-kind focal point. Quartzite carries a subtle pattern with less dramatic shifts between lighter and darker areas across its surface. Its natural subtlety spotlights the inherent grains and tones of the stone material itself.
Durability and Performance
Understandably, durability weighs as a top concern for most homeowners. Countertops need to stand up to years of everyday use while retaining their beauty. Both granite and quartzite earn high marks in this category, but a few key differences exist.
Scratch and Chip Resistance
On the Mohs mineral hardness scale, granite ranks about an 8 out of 10, making it extremely scratch resistant. In other words, it is very unlikely to damage under normal household use. Quartzite follows closely behind around a 7 on the hardness scale. While still durable, quartzite presents a slightly softer surface that can scratch more easily over time.
Stain Resistance
When properly sealed, granite and quartzite offer similar stain resistance to spills and messes. However, quartzite naturally absorbs more moisture, requiring resealing slightly more often to maintain performance. Less porous granite only needs resealing every couple years in residential settings.
Heat Tolerance
Both stones hold up well against heat exposure from hot pans or baking sheets. But hairline cracks can develop more readily in quartzite under extreme or sudden temperature fluctuations. Granite better resists thermal shock overall.
Maintenance Needs
To retain the original beauty of natural stone surfaces, some degree of regular maintenance is essential no matter which material you choose. However, a few small upkeep differences exist between granite and quartzite.
Most quartzite requires resealing about every 1-2 years on average to refresh water repellency. More porous areas may need sealing as often as every 6 months. Granite needs less frequent renewal of protective sealants - usually once every 3-5 years suits residential granite countertops just fine.
Granite also demands a bit more careful attention when cleaning. Harsh chemical cleaners can dull the surface over time, as can excessive scrubbing. Quartzite stands up better to vigorous scouring. But with both stones, gentle daily upkeep best preserves their original shine.
With so many variables to weigh, deciding between materials ultimately requires narrowing priorities. Budget limitations can understandably guide decisions towards more affordable granite. For those drawn to rare, captivating colors, granite provides far more variety.
Others may favor quartzite for its distinctive natural veining in soothing neutral tones. And despite the need for careful maintenance, quartzite's heat resistance and non-porous surface make a sensible choice for heavy day-to-day use.
Visiting local stone suppliers allows seeing slabs in person rather than relying on photos. Speaking with an experienced kitchen contractor also proves invaluable for gaining professional perspectives on each material's functional pros and cons. Combining first-hand visual research with practical guidance lets homeowners select the best granite or quartzite to match their space, lifestyle and budget.